This is the sequel to Trickster's Choice, beginning six months or so after the events in that novel. Alianne Cooper, daughter of Alanna the Lioness and George (Tortallan spymaster) has won her wager with the god Kyprioth and kept Sarai and Dove (the two elder daughters of the Balitangs) alive, but she has elected to stay in the Copper Isles and see the half-blood Queen crowned.We begin the novel with the Balitang family arriving back in the city of Rajmuat, plunging themselves into political intrigue and gaining the attention of the Rittevon royal family, who suspect the Balitangs of having intentions towards the throne. While this is occurring, Aly and the other raka conspirators create civil unrest in the city in order to push the populace into rebellion against the ruling monarchs.Aly spends a great deal of time desk-bound, reading reports, or visiting with the other conspirators - and this is where I feel the novel really lacked sparkle. The book reads like an account of someone doing a job - recruiting, reading reports, attending meetings. It just isn't all that exciting.Tamora Pierce confesses in her acknowledgements that she has delighted in following J K Rowling's lead in writing larger books for children. This is all very well, but I think Pierce writes better in a shorter format. Her original quartets about Tortall were strong, snappy and fast-paced. The larger books suffer from bloating and, here, too many tedious details about the reports Aly reads and visits to the palace were included. Two of the early chapters in the novel concern Sarai and Dove visiting the palace, and I found it extremely hard to push through those - I've never had such trouble with Pierce's books before.I also found that Sarai became a pretty dislikeable character - spoilt, headstrong, and only thinking of herself. I was thankful when we reached the fate Pierce gave to her, and Dove came to the forefront. While speaking about the characters, one of my favourites from Trickster's Choice - Nawat Crow - was absent for much of this novel, and his loss removed a lot of the gentle humour that delighted me so in the first book.Another complaint I have is the "MacGuffin" of the darking characters. Sure, they're pretty cute - although they do have a tendency to come across in a childish manner with their lack of adult speech - but they do make Aly's job enormously easy when she is spying on the palace. It is a very lazy plot device and leads Aly to suffer no real peril or cause her to have to really think through obtaining information.Since we're on the subject of peril, none of these characters seem in any real danger. Yes, a few of them die but this almost seems as though Pierce is going through a checklist and ticking off "necessary death of beloved character to generate scenes of mourning". I never felt that any of the main characters were in any danger of not surviving.I did enjoy some parts of the book - the kudarung (winged horses of all sizes and colours) were a nice addition; Nawat's return was very welcome; and the epilogue did a neat job of showing a few nice details of Aly's life some months after the end of the revolution - but overall I was disappointed. This seemed Pierce-by-the-numbers, and it came across that she didn't have much fun writing the story. In her Notes at the end, Tamora Pierce encourages those interested to seek out historical sources of actual revolution and conquest - it is a shame that, in this case, those sources would be more exciting.
I would have read this book right after finishing Trickster's Choice but I'm always afraid there'll be too much rehashing of previous events etc., which gets really annoying. Instead, there's very very little, and what there is is slipped in there naturally. I was rather surprised at the things I'd forgotten, like about Duke Mequen! That was pretty significant, I'm surprised I'd forgotten that.The Balitang family return to the capital of Rajmuat where the formidable matriarch of the family, Aunt Niritin, has things well in hand. The conspiracy amongst the Raka and the household servants, with Aly as spymaster, has some serious clout and Dove on their side. The Regents of the Rittevon boy-king, Dunevon, are suspicious, prickly, unloved and reactive; it doesn't take much from Aly to aggravate their worst points and turn the populace against them, though they certainly didn't need much help for that. Nawat, the crow-man, leaves Aly to help the rebels on other islands and to grow into himself. Gifts from Aly's home make things really interesting.The relationships and politics in this particular volume are handled very well - never boring, even the plotting is exciting. What Pierce did with Sarai and Dove I absolutely love - she's not an author to be boxed in but allows for change and fluidity, and it worked out better than the original plan. I adored the darkings, which were very original and fresh and entertaining. While I did find that Aly's personal thoughts and feelings weren't delved into enough, especially in relation to Nawat, had I been reading this at 14, say, I would have been very satisfied. Probably my imagination was more active at the time and needed less direction?There's great intelligence and craftiness in this duology, as well as enjoyable characters and unique fantasy elements. Highly recommended; just don't be distracted by a few cringe-inducing past tense verbs - "treaded" is NOT a word, the past tense of "tread" is "trod". Grrr.
What do You think about Trickster's Queen (2005)?
A second and final book ABSOLUTELY AWESOME !!Back in the good favours of the regents, Aly and her companions returned to the capital of Rajmuat and begin to actively prepare the revolution to overthrow the Rittevon and put Sarai on the throne. But amid the intrigues of the court, paranoia and murders, Aly will have to use all her talents as a spy to keep unharmed the Balitang family and help the returning of Kyprioth and of a raka queen on the throne ...LOVED this conclusion !! The author's style is still pleasant (full of humor, sarcasm and also scenes which broke your heart and other really harsh that make us aware of the hardness of the choices sometimes ...), the universe is still amazing (I loved the darkings !! I sooo want one too ><) and the plot and subplots (to a background of racism and political intrigues) are AMAZING here and gain a level of complexity really exciting : I am a HUGE fan of court intrigues and espionage so there I was in heaven =D (I admit I cried at the scene of the "shipwreck", I kind of expected a miracle and my heart broke ... But I totally expected the change of situation with Sarai, it's been several chapters since I thought she would make a very bad queen (too irresponsible) so I was pretty pleased with the turnaround ><)The characters are still fascinating and although many die in this book (hey it's not a cakewalk, it's war !!), it's well done =)I'm still a HUGE fan of Aly who remains my favorite character in the series with her life as a spy, her Machiavellian mind, her charming side, her sassy replies while remaining human with feelings and weaknesses =) Her relationship with Nawat evolves considerably (WOW WOW !! I must admit that I was afraid of finding myself with a mushy couple of teenagers kissing and everything and finally, nOT AT ALL !! Nawat is not a pushover and he TOTALLY knows how to take the lead when necessary =) (Yes, there is a sex scene but it's very well written and rather soft =))Other secondary characters are just as interesting as before in this book, including the Balitang family that has strong female members like Winna (she evolves a lot and proves to be a true leading lady) and Dove (who is one of my favorite characters, a discreet girl, not extraordinary beautiful but nice, intelligent, very mature and a perfect queen). I loved to see more gods although Kyprioth remains my favorite (in that book, he's a much more believable god : funny, clever but ultimately inhumane to the point of being sometimes cruel ...)Special mention for Taybur Sibigat, the captain of the guard too insightful that I totally loved and that I would have liked to see more ><) and would have liked to know more about the thief that Kyprioth had found =)Ahhh and of course I would have liked more books ><)
—Lea Bourg'
Turns out I'm not going to write a full review of this, but I did want to get some quick thoughts down about it while they're still fresh. Mostly I just want to talk about how fun it was to read a book about a girl who is so competent at something girls aren't usually good at in novels, and who has a chance to do something serious, with real consequence. I liked the twist half-way through with Dove and Sarai, and I love love love Aly and Nawat together. This doesn't get five stars from me, though, because I feel like it got a bit bogged down with all the spy/revolution stuff for a while and forgot about its characters. There was just so much detail that Aly had to take in as the spymaster for the rebellion, and we had to hear about it too, that it just got overwhelming sometimes. It was a relief when actual things would happen to Aly or her friends/co-conspirators because then it felt like a novel again, rather than a historical chronicle.
—Ashley
To be honest I was a little disappointed by this book. Usually I fly through Tamora Pierce's books because they capture my imagination and I cannot bear to put them down until the adventure is finished.They keep you interested with twists and turns and characters that you want to call friends.The first book in the set of 2 - Trickster's Choice - was a great read. The characters were well defined and you believed in them. The story line was intriguing and different from her other books - but in a good way. There were the usual elements of magic, love, honour and hard choices. Then came along this - the second book. Suddenly everything ... slowed ... down. One chapter became the same as the next. Plot lines became obvious and certain characters started to grate on your nerves. Characters you were supposed to cheer for. It takes about half the book before you actually find yourself once again flipping pages in anticipation.Magic is over used, there is no challenge as everything seems to easy for Aly (the main character) and the villains are very flat and two dimensional.
—Miranda Harvey