A ring was found at a crime scene in France. It was badly damaged in the fire set to cover Ben’s murder. They were able to establish it was from St. John Vianney College, and your graduating class.” Dave and Jill had told Carly the whole story about Ben Pierce’s murder, about Andrew and his proposition to her to spy for him, as well as the details Dave had found out surrounding Ben’s death. Carly sat next to Jill on the sofa, and both women stared at Carly’s dad. “But you left out the most important thing,” Carly said. “Who did Ben Pierce meet with? Surely someone knows.” Dave blinked. “Both of my sources say no one knows the man’s name. And Ben’s ring was on his body, so they think the one they found must belong to the murderer.” “And the murder happened in Paris, right?” Jill asked. Where Max lives. A coincidence that was feeling more and more sinister to her worried brain.