Boastful dog turns off his friends by claiming he is the best at...everything! They feel sad until they affirm their abilities. I have to say, the page where dog is crying because everyone has smacked him down esteem-wise (as he has done to them) is slightly heartbreaking. All's well that ends with a hug, I guess? I found this book a bit...awkward. Not one I would pick for storytime (I don't enjoy shocked and saddened mommy faces glaring back at me from the storytime audience, no i do not) but if a parent approached me troubled by their child's boastful ways, this may be a good suggestion. The conceit (pun intended) of this picture book is successful, but the execution is a bit clunky. Lucy Cousins' illustrations in bright, vivid colors fly off the page, making for a fun romp through a simple but important message. Dog's comeuppances are well-deserved and amusing. The book's final page is thought-provoking... is Cousins indicating that a trait such as conceit is innate and unchangeable? Or that everything that had been taught before was forgotten in an instant? A mixed message that undermines the main point.
What do You think about I'm The Best (2010)?
My two little girls really needed to hear this book more than once!
—Rita
